R5 rolling shutter in sword fight

[tpatana]

Most of the time I shoot 1st curtain but recently quite often towards the final matches, I switch to electronic to get more fps. In my sports it doesn't really do too much rolling shutter as we don't have round things like most other sports. However, for someone who does the sport (and especially has taken ton of pictures), here and there I can spot bend in the sword which shouldn't be there. For example the sword on left:

And we get lot of natural bend too, especially on contact:

But I think the rolling shutter is non-issue for my sports, most people wouldn't notice anything wrong with that picture.

 

[Only RF]

This is a tough one. Photographers will notice this while the general public will likely not. Also how would anyone know if you did this on purpose to show movement? You are the artist presenting your work.

Rolling shutter can be an issue. Your shutter speeds seem a bit too slow for that type of action. Motion blur in the swords. File 2. If you hit something that hard with a flexible sword it is going to bend. The tip of the sword in the 1st file is showing blur but hard to tell if the slight bend is due to rolling shutter or is due to the slow shutter speed. I don't know how flexible the swords are. However you are saying that you only noticed this using ES and not 1st curtain sync?

 

[Kamoshika]

This is a tough one. Photographers will notice this while the general public will likely not. Also how would anyone know if you did this on purpose to show movement? You are the artist presenting your work.

Rolling shutter can be an issue. Your shutter speeds seem a bit too slow for that type of action. Motion blur in the swords. File 2. If you hit something that hard with a flexible sword it is going to bend. The tip of the sword in the 1st file is showing blur but hard to tell if the slight bend is due to rolling shutter or is due to the slow shutter speed. I don't know how flexible the swords are. However you are saying that you only noticed this using ES and not 1st curtain sync?

I was thinking the same. That seems like a normal amount of bend for a flexible kendo shinai.

 

[Only RF]

I was thinking the same. That seems like a normal amount of bend for a flexible kendo shinai.

Thanks for providing the name of it.

 

[Only RF]

Thanks for providing the name of it.

Well I wasn't going to say anything but I'm fascinated by Samurai culture. Obviously I don't know a lot. I think they have the most unique uniforms on the planet. When we were in Tokyo about 4 years ago we found the Samurai museum. I didn't know Lucas based Darth Vader on a Samurai. That was what they told us anyway. Now when I watch the movies I see they fight with two hands on the light sabre.

 

[tpatana]

This is a tough one. Photographers will notice this while the general public will likely not. Also how would anyone know if you did this on purpose to show movement? You are the artist presenting your work.

Rolling shutter can be an issue. Your shutter speeds seem a bit too slow for that type of action. Motion blur in the swords. File 2. If you hit something that hard with a flexible sword it is going to bend. The tip of the sword in the 1st file is showing blur but hard to tell if the slight bend is due to rolling shutter or is due to the slow shutter speed. I don't know how flexible the swords are. However you are saying that you only noticed this using ES and not 1st curtain sync?

For one, I generally like the ~1/500 on shutter to give bit movement for the swords, makes pictures feel more alive than static posing. I often get some bend or movement.

The bend on 1st pic is wrong, I just know/feel that it doesn't bend like that on 1st curtain but I see it occasionally on the pics taken with ES. In general they can bend bit when swinging and especially on contact. But that one is bending wrong so it's caused by ES.

 

[Only RF]

For one, I generally like the ~1/500 on shutter to give bit movement for the swords, makes pictures feel more alive than static posing. I often get some bend or movement.

The bend on 1st pic is wrong, I just know/feel that it doesn't bend like that on 1st curtain but I see it occasionally on the pics taken with ES. In general they can bend bit when swinging and especially on contact. But that one is bending wrong so it's caused by ES.

That would make sense.

 

[Series6]

George Lucas admitted being influenced by Akita Kurosawa many times. The original Star Wars was inspired by Hidden Fortress.

 

[Only RF]

George Lucas admitted being influenced by Akita Kurosawa many times. The original Star Wars was inspired by Hidden Fortress.

Interesting. Thanks

 

[Kerro]

Seeing how they are so flexible I was wondering what is a kendo shinai is made of?

 

[tpatana]

Seeing how they are so flexible I was wondering what is a kendo shinai is made of?

It's bamboo. They are not that flexible when you try to bend them with hand, but on impact with fast swings they flex amazing amount.